Parents Instructing Challenged Children
Some of the Advantages of Home Schooling a Child with Special Needs
This list comes from Barb Mulvey, former Director of PICC, and the experiences
she heard from other families since May 1986.
For more information about PICC (Parents Instructing Challenged Children)
LEAH a network of families currently home schooling children with handicapping conditions,
call (631) 473-8315, or write to PICC at 167 Hickory Street, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776-2117.
E-mail address: piccleah@verizon.net
(1) Comprehensive, consistent curriculum
- You order the materials, so you see that the curriculum follows
along in a logical format and that there are no gaps in your child's
learning. You can order 2nd grade reading, 5th grade math, and tailor
your child's curriculum to your child.
- Public schools either order one curriculum for everyone or allow
the teacher to pick the curriculum for the group, as teachers change
so does the curriculum. My daughter "studied" dinosaurs 5 times in 5
years, but was never taught how to read or do math.
(2) Socialization
- Your child spends much more quality time with adults in the
home school situation, watching how adults handle the things that come
up in life.
- In public school, your child will be segregated by handicapping
classification and removed from the mainstream and/or put into the
mainstream which is the only age segregated society we have in our
country today. Students have much less time interacting with adults
and tend to develop the herd mentality of their peer group.
(3) Real life experiences
- Your child goes with you to the bank, to the store, to the
doctor, to vote, etc. He/she learns by your example how these things
work.
- Public schools do role playing and create imaginary stores to
teach children these skills.
(4) Everyday living skills
- Are taught right in the home as necessary, as a normal part of
every day life, day in and day out. A child has time to learn and
practice these skills.
- In public school, planning meals, doing dishes, cleaning the
house, washing clothes, etc are all things relegated to a special
class at a special time. If your child doesn't take that class or if
he/she is absent the day they cover a particular skill, they are
at a loss.
(5) Health
- Home school children are healthier for two, possibly three, reasons:
- They aren't exposed to every contagion that rages through
the schools.
- If they do start to become ill, they can receive rest,
medicine, or a trip to the doctor without sending messages
back and forth through school personnel.
- They are less stressed out because they are not in the
hyped up environment of the public school.
(6) Special Needs
- Home school students with special needs can progress truly at
their own speed and can take time to finish their work. You can
take side trips and explore tangents that come up during your
progress through a topic. Questions can be answered when they
come up. (Math questions don't have to wait to math class.)
- No matter what a public school teacher tries, he/she is bound by
public school hours and must conform to the public school schedule
(gym here, music there, lunch, etc). They cannot use the entire day
and cannot indulge tangents.
(7) Individualized instruction
- You have access to your child, one-on-one, 24 hours per day.
You can take advantage of Saturdays and Sundays. If your child's
most productive hours are outside the times when the busses roll,
you can use them. You have no other students (other than family
members) requiring your attention. Often those family members are
resources too as the entire family invests in this loved-one's education.
- Public school teachers cannot afford to spend too much time or
attention on one child. If they do, that child becomes the "pet" and is
ostracized by the rest of the class. As a result, public school teachers
have a difficult time following through with each child. If a teacher has
6 children in a class and has a 6 hour day which she totally dedicated
to individual attention, she could only spend 1 hour per day teaching
each child. Now take out of each day 1 hour for lunch, time for gym,
art, music, and other activities (not to mention crowd and riot control).
Then add in your child's therapies (PT, OT, etc) . Now you can see
the impossible task the public school teacher has and you start to
understand why your child is having difficulties.
(8) Carry over of therapies
- Most parents understand their child's handicapping condition and
have spent many hours with doctors and therapists learning what kinds
of things help enhance their therapeutic endeavors and what things
hinder progress in therapeutic terms. At home, parents can see that
their child is sitting in appropriate positions, doing things that will help
their growth and development.
- Public school teachers have many responsibilities and can find
it difficult keeping track of which child is to sit which way, etc. Many
parents have told me their child's public school teacher never consulted
with the therapists and had no clue to their child's therapeutic needs.
(9) Discipline
- Parents want their children (regardless of handicapping condition
or not) to grow up to be productive members of society. In order to do
that, children must learn to behave in appropriate ways, to develop
good manners, to interact positively with people, to persevere when
things get tough. These are all things which can be learned at home,
with good role models, high expectations, and discipline.
- Public schools are hamstrung by two different philosophies. The
first is their low expectations based on the child's diagnosis. Public
school officials tend to look at disabilities rather than abilities and tend
to teach these children to give up rather than try. The result is that
many special needs children get the message that they aren't
responsible, they are stupid, they can't learn and they don't want to.
The second philosophy is the permissive environment of a discipline
neutered education system. Where there is no order and no protection,
students may subjected to ridicule by others. Many parents pull their
children from public school because they are afraid their children are
learning to hate learning.
(10) Joy
- One of the wonderful by-products of home schooling a child with
special needs comes when you have been working for weeks or months
on a concept and it finally finds its way into their understanding.
When that light finally goes on and your child says, "Oh, now I see!"
there is just nothing like it. Remember your child's first step or first
word? Can you imagine not being there when it happens? We get the
same feeling when our child finally learns 7x7 is 49 an doesn't have to
look in his/her multiplication tables, or reads their first sentence.
(11) Fanning the flames
- When a child "loves" a certain topic, the parent in the home school
can fan those flames and encourage that love of learning. The child can
spend extra hours pursuing knowledge in that area.
- Public school officials have their canned curriculums and discourage
trips "off the reservation". Your child will learn the public school way
and in the form they chose, whether that form of learning is consistent
with your child's learning style (audio, visual, or tactile) or not. They
are also limited by time.
(12) Family values
- You can do Bible study in your home school, teach your faith to
your children in Biblical fashion, "Impress them on your children, talk
about them when you sit at home and when you walk along the road,
when you lie down, and when you get up." Deuteronomy 6:7
- When your children are in public school, you have little or no time
to influence their faith. You have the hour before the bus comes (which
can be chaotic) and the hours after school when everyone's exhausted
and tired of structured (school) activities. For many that's the time they
are heading off for after school activities. So people resort to having
others teach their faith to their children (Sunday school teachers, the
youth sermon in church, etc). Children learn that faith is something
practiced exclusively on Sundays (a mythical something removed from
the "real world") and that learning takes place on week days from 9-3
from September to June.
(13) Play time
- When you home school, your child has time to be a child. Once
their work for the day is done, they are free to relax and play. Children
need time to be children.
- When you have a child with special needs in public school and
you "reinforce their learning after school," your child has very little
time to relax in an unstructured way. This creates burn out & resentment.
If you are "reinforcing your child's learning after school, " you are
already home schooling � after school.
(14) Hard work
- It's very hard work and for beginners it's scary. It's a big step
with lots of responsibility and there are many skeptics in this world.
But the Lord is faithful. He will not call you to do something you and
He cannot do together. You will learn as much or more than your
children about His world and about yourselves. It builds character
in parents and children alike as they learn mentally, spiritually, and
physically together. When you face difficulties your faith in the Lord
will grow as you turn to Him for guidance, grace, and strength.